Marilize Jacobs, founder of VocalCord PR and Reputation Management writes that comms teams measure everyone’s reputation but their own. As 2027 plans are signed off, she adds that comms teams should read their own reviews first.
Imagine a comms team had a Google review. Five stars from the CEO’s assistant, ‘Always helpful.’ One star from finance, ‘Lots of activity. Never worked out what we were paying for.’ Three stars from sales, ‘Only called us when something went wrong.’
In July, Richard Thompson, interim head of communications at American Public Media Group, asked on LinkedIn how well comms manages its own brand inside the organisation. Citing Gartner’s 2026 CCO Spend Survey, he reported that 46% of chief communications officers say their budgets have been cut.
Jacobs adds that reputation is comms’ job. Everyone creates it, but comms is the function paid to know what the world thinks. A team that cannot say what its own reputation is should not be surprised when its budget is the first to move. ‘So measure it, the way we measure it for clients,’ she says.
Why now? Because 2027 is being planned now. November is AMEC’s annual Measurement Month, and Ornico’s latest South African benchmark dates from November 2025. AMEC’s Barcelona Principles 4.0 make clear, measurable objectives a prerequisite. If a team’s 2027 goals and measures are not agreed by now, Jacobs says, it is already late.
AMEC’s Integrated Evaluation Framework runs from objectives through outputs, outtakes and outcomes to impact. Jacobs suggests applying the middle three to the team:
– Outputs: what the team produces. In Ornico’s 2025 SA PR Measurement Landscape Report, 79% of practitioners measure outputs.
– Outtakes: what colleagues think of the team. This is the Google review, and few teams ask for it.
– Outcomes: what colleagues do differently because of the team. Do they call comms before an announcement, or after? In the same research, 60% measure outcomes, up from 47%.
Strategic access is the gap. Around 60% of practitioners say they have it. Dr Tersia Landsberg, who presented the research, puts it bluntly, ‘If you have no idea what the business goals are, it is because you do not have strategic access.’
Where It Breaks In Practice
Reputation is not comms’ alone to build, Jacobs notes. Every department has to work together, and in practice they often do not. Marketing and PR rarely talk to each other, and PR is usually bought in after the brief is written, when the story has already been decided. In owner-run firms the freelancer on social media and the agency on the press release may never have met, and the owner is the only link between them. Her advice is to put PR in the room when the brief is written, and to agree one audience, one message and one body of evidence before anyone executes.
But Who Has The Time?
Many comms teams are one or two people, and the Ornico report names the same limits: thin budgets, little time and few research skills. So Jacobs says not to add a workstream. Gini Dietrich, author of the PESO model, offers a rule for busy executives that works here too: find an existing habit and add one small step. Jacobs sees three ways:
– Track the team’s hours for one week. After each task, note whether it was making (writing, designing), sending (posting, pitching) or advising (decision meetings, briefing the CEO, deciding whether to say anything). If nearly all the hours are making and sending, that is how colleagues see the team.
– Ask ten colleagues outside comms three questions, as the last item in a meeting that already exists. Keep it anonymous. When did you last involve us before a decision, and if not, why not? Describe our team in one word. What do you wish we did that we do not? Read the one-star answers first. If the CEO and the CFO describe two different teams, the brand is inconsistent.
– Write one sentence on what comms contributes to business outcomes. Thompson’s test: could your CFO repeat it back, unprompted, when budgets tighten?
Editors Review You Too
Dietrich notes that journalists now see dozens of AI-generated expert quotes a day and are getting good at ignoring them. Generic, polished pitches, Jacobs says, write their own one-star review.
The Review You Cannot Trust
The one review a team cannot trust is the one it wrote itself. Advertising value equivalents (AVEs) price coverage as if it were advertising. The team sets the rate and marks its own homework: paying itself five stars. AMEC’s Barcelona Principles 4.0 call AVEs invalid measures that should not be used. In the Ornico research, 36% of practitioners still report them, down from 63% in 2022.
What A Good Review Looks Like
Dietrich says thought leadership is for deals and a seat at the table, not likes. A good comms reputation looks the same: being in the room when decisions are made. A team’s reputation already exists in the minds of everyone in the building, Jacobs concludes. Go and read it.
VOCALCORD PR AND REPUTATION MANAGEMENT
marilizejacobs@icloud.com








