Anne-marie le Roux, a lecturer in Strategy and Leadership at Stellenbosch Business School Executive Development asks, where is the real customer? We seem to be living in an age where businesses are trying to escape real customer engagement. In the boardrooms where business consultants see executives marvel at the massive revenue opportunities AI will bring (as they should), it is difficult not to also consider the opportunities being lost in showing true customer empathy.
A recent example illustrates the point. A customer reports a simple delivery mix-up in store. The solution was obvious. It required common sense. Instead, the rigid, automated customer service process and procedure left no room for any decision-making power at the point of contact, where the real customer experience was actually happening.
The employee was left entirely disempowered. The customer walked away confused and disappointed. And no data was captured to fix the root issue in the future.
In another instance, during a customer review session, a company’s internal AI dashboard reported a two-minute longest call handle time (LHT). It looked hyper-efficient on paper. However, some verbal complaints slipped through the wall and contradicted this. After a few test calls, the real longest wait emerged: seven minutes.
The lesson from both examples is uncomfortable. What looks efficient from inside the business can feel very different to the customer on the other side of the interaction. Are our data touchpoints giving us the real picture? And do we even calculate the opportunity cost when so many of these experiences are not captured and, therefore, are not managed?
The Current Bias Dilemma
The pressure to drive efficiencies and embrace newness has intensified. AI efficiency has become a commodity, while the move to create real customer value and growth has been slower than the obvious cost-cutting benefits. Data is measurable, scalable and predictable. And allowing for the churn of losing a few complaining customers can make financial sense. While companies publicise their commitment to customer experience, financial investment often tells a different story.
Data systems designed to track, target and monetise customer behaviour are prioritised over real customer voices. There is a tendency to believe that interrogating customer data and talking about the customer makes more sense than getting our hands dirty and going out there with the orientation that this is the real picture, rather than an analytical picture sliced and diced to prove a point.
In fact, executives can be heard eloquently talking about ‘my customers say…’, only for it to emerge that no real customer engagement has taken place since the executive seat was occupied. And this is where the real disconnect begins: the distance between where the customer engages with the company and where the power sits to make decisions. Increasingly, the walls between the two are being built by technology rather than bridged by it.
For customers, there are few things more satisfying than an effective self-help process. Yet many customers have also been at the receiving end of frustrating chatbots or endless loops of conversational AI that recognise the keywords, but not the complexity or human context.
Worse yet, if a customer is finally directed to an agent, the frustration experienced through the limited decision options may not be visible to that agent. The customer is back to square one. This is not an argument against AI. It is an argument for asking whether we are using it to remove friction for the customer or simply to remove cost for the business.
Measuring The Wrong Things, Beautifully
The most important metrics at the moment seem to be those that optimise AI investments: graphs showing plummeting customer calls, lightning-fast ticket resolution times, fewer transactions at customer service desks. In the rush to implement measurable savings, businesses can report highly efficient balance sheets in the short term, while the unintended impact on the lifetime value of customers remains largely unseen. The focus on measuring what customers want is rarely qualified by the why.
An experienced account manager or support agent does not just read words. They experience the emotions and can translate unarticulated customer needs. They notice the customer who walks out of a store without transacting because there was no empty seat or cart, or because there was simply no available person or product to assist them. These are moments that data may or may not register as a lost transaction, but rarely explain. And therein lies the danger: companies may be successfully optimising their most valuable customers right out the door.
The real AI winners will not necessarily be the companies with the cheapest customer engagement, but those that use AI to make human interactions deeply impactful.
JIGSAW
www.jigsawpr.co.za








